Skip to content
NOWCAST KOCO 10:30pm-11pm Sunday Night
Live Now
Advertisement

Oklahoma ME releases Nex Benedict's full autopsy. Here's what we know about the investigation, fight

Below is a look at the circumstances surrounding Benedict's death and the investigation into it

Oklahoma ME releases Nex Benedict's full autopsy. Here's what we know about the investigation, fight

Below is a look at the circumstances surrounding Benedict's death and the investigation into it

ALL RIGHT, AUDREY, THANKS FOR THAT UPDATE. AND THIS MORNING NEW REACTION COMING IN AFTER A NEW REPORT FROM THE STATE MEDICAL EXAMINER REVEALED 16 YEAR-OLD NEXT BENEDICT DIED AS A RESULT OF SUICIDE. THE NON-BINARY STUDENT’S DEATH DREW NATIONAL ATTENTION, AND CAMERON SIBERT JOINS US IN STUDIO NOW THIS MORNING WITH MORE ON THE MEDICAL EXAMINER’S REPORT. IT’S A MAJOR DEVELOPMENT IN THIS STORY, GUYS. A LOT OF QUESTIONS ABOUT HOW NEXT DIED. NOW ANSWER JUST SHE THEY DIED JUST ONE DAY AFTER A FIGHT IN THE HIGH SCHOOL BATHROOM. THE DAY AFTER THAT FIGHT. NEXT, HIS MOTHER CALLING 911, ASKING FOR MEDICS, SAYING THE TEENAGER WAS POSTURING IN THEIR HANDS, WERE CURLING UP, ACCORDING TO THE MEDICAL EXAMINER REPORT. NEXT IS PROBABLE CAUSE OF DEATH WAS COMBINED TOXICITY OF TWO DRUGS DIED AND HYDRAZINE, COMMONLY KNOWN AS BENADRYL AND ALSO FLUOXETINE THAT’S KNOWN AS PROZAC. ON WEDNESDAY, WE SPOKE TO OKLAHOMA’S ONLY NON-BINARY LAWMAKER JUST MOMENTS AFTER THIS NEW REPORT. WHETHER OR NOT IT WAS A SUICIDE, THE RHETORIC THAT WE SHARE ON THIS HOUSE FLOOR, THE BILLS THAT WE WRITE, NOT EVEN JUST THE ONES THAT WE PASS, RIGHT, BUT THE ONES THAT WE WRITE, HAVE A VERY DETRIMENTAL EFFECT ON THE YOUTH OF OKLAHOMA. REPRESENTATIVE MARI TURNER PLANS TO JOIN A MARCH FOR NEXT BENEDICT TODAY. THAT’S AT THE STATE CAPITOL. REACTION ALSO COMING IN FROM STATE SUPERINTENDENT RYAN WALTERS YESTERDAY. HE SAYS THE LOSS IS TRAGIC FOR THE FAMILY, COMMUNITY AND OUR STATE. HE SAYS HE REMAINS MORE COMMITTED THAN EVER TO NEVER BACKING DOWN FROM A WOKE MOB. KOCO PLANS TO REMAIN COMMITTED TO TELLING ALL SIDES OF THIS STORY. WE WILL ALSO BE LEARNING MORE ABOUT NEX’S DEATH WHEN THE MEDICAL EXAMINER RELEASES THE FULL REPORT. THAT’S ON MARCH 27TH. THE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF E
Advertisement
Oklahoma ME releases Nex Benedict's full autopsy. Here's what we know about the investigation, fight

Below is a look at the circumstances surrounding Benedict's death and the investigation into it

Nex Benedict, a 16-year-old nonbinary student, died on Feb. 8 – a day after authorities said they got into a fight in a bathroom at Owasso High School.| MORE | Medical examiner's report on Nex Benedict's death prompts reaction from LGBTQ+ communityA little more than a month following the fight and Benedict's death, the Oklahoma Medical Examiner's Office released a summary autopsy report ruling the 16-year-old's death a suicide. Weeks later, the medical examiner released the full autopsy report into their death. The student's death prompted a local and federal investigation and has made international headlines.Below is a look at the circumstances surrounding Benedict's death and the investigation into it. NOTE: The details below are disturbing. Also, KOCO 5 uses they/them pronouns for Nex Benedict, but this article uses direct quotes from those involved and court documents, which use she/her/daughter.The autopsy reportOn March 13, the Oklahoma State Medical Examiner's Office released a summary autopsy report stating Benedict's manner of death was a suicide. The summary autopsy report from the medical examiner's office lists the probable cause of death as diphenhydramine and fluoxetine combined toxicity. Diphenhydramine is an antihistamine to relieve allergies, and fluoxetine is an antidepressant.The full autopsy released on March 27 listed the toxicology report from Benedict. Below are the results of the toxicology report:Fluoxetine:1.2 mcg/mL - (Hospital Blood A; 02/08/24 at 1600 hrs)1.9 mcg/mL - (Femoral Blood)2. Norfluoxetine:0.89 mcg/mL - (Hospital Blood A; 02/08/24 at 1600 hrs)1.4 mcg/mL - (Femoral Blood)3. Diphenhydramine15 mcg/mL - (Hospital Blood A; 02/08/24 at 1600 hrs)25 mcg/mL - (Femoral Blood)The autopsy found no lethal trauma to Benedict, but some bruises and cuts were found on their body. Investigators said that Benedict was reported to have headaches and seizure-like activity before they were found unresponsive. In late February, the Owasso Police Department released an investigation update saying preliminary information from the autopsy report indicated that Benedict did not die as a result of trauma. Handwritten notes that were also suggestive of self-harm were found in Benedict's bedroom and provided to law enforcement by their family, according to the report. There are resources available if you or anyone you know is struggling with mental health. You can call the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline by dialing 988.The bathroom fightAccording to police and Owasso Public Schools officials, a fight occurred on the afternoon of Feb. 7 in a bathroom on the west campus. They said the fight lasted for less than two minutes and was broken up by other students in the bathroom as well as a staff member supervising outside of the bathroom.Once the fight had been broken up, district officials said all students involved walked under their own power to the assistant principal's office and the nurse's office.| MORE | Parents of Owasso High School student who died correct errors of misidentifying their childBody camera video from an Owasso Police officer showed Benedict telling their account of what happened, saying they had finished stacking chairs in the lunch room and went to the bathroom. A group of freshmen also were in the bathroom when Benedict told the officer "I was talking with my friends, they were talking with their friends. And we were laughing, and they had said something like, 'Why do they laugh like that?' And they were talking about us in front of us."Benedict then said they poured water from a water bottle on the girls, "and all three of them came at me.""They came at me, they grabbed on my hair. I grabbed on them. I threw one of them into a paper towel dispenser, and then they got my legs out from under me," Benedict said. "Got me on the ground and started beating the (expletive) out of me. And then my friends tried to jump in and help, but I'm not sure. I blacked out."Security footage from Owasso High School showed that everyone involved in the fight was able to walk to the assistant principal's and nurse's offices under their own power.Why didn't the school call police? Although the district said Owasso High School administrators followed the initial protocols when a fight occurs, police said they were not notified of a fight happening on school grounds until an officer spoke with Benedict and their mother at the hospital.When speaking with Nex and Sue Benedict at the hospital, the body camera video shows that Sue Benedict wanted the officer to find out why school administrators didn't notify police of the fight.| MORE | Vigils held nationwide for nonbinary Oklahoma teenager who died day after school bathroom fight"They are in the wrong for that," Sue Benedict said.The officer told the Benedicts that he would get with the school the following morning to try to get information about the fight. He added "we'll definitely have a talk about that" about why police weren't notified of the fight."They know better," the officer said. "And I will say for what it's worth, (name redacted), I've worked with her for five years. She's typically spot on, meaning the one who was with us in our conversation. She's one of the best in that school of handling. If I was a betting person, I would venture to say that there was something else a little more pressing that was going on – not that this was not. But I think, like anything, maybe it was a little overwhelming, maybe she had something else going on and it just slipped her mind probably. Because as soon as I sent her a text message that said, 'Do you know anything about a fight at school? Because I'm going to the ER,' and she was, 'Oh my gosh. Yes. Can I call you?'" The officer said the administrator said in the text exchange that there was an incident at the school and that they'd discuss it the following day.None of the statements from Owasso police or the school district addressed why police weren't called after the fight took place.The Owasso Police Department's investigationAccording to police, officers were called around 3:30 p.m. on Feb. 7 to Bailey Medical Center by the parent of a 16-year-old female Owasso High School student. The parent told police that they wanted to report that the student was involved in a physical altercation earlier that day while at Owasso High School.The police department's initial statement said, "No report of the fight was made to Owasso police prior to the notification at the hospital." Information was taken by a school resource officer who responded to the hospital.| MORE | Owasso police officers suspected foul play was involved in Nex Benedict’s death, affidavit saysOn Feb. 8, the Owasso Police Department learned that the 16-year-old was rushed back to the hospital, where the student was pronounced dead."It is not known at this time if this latest medical incident is related to the previous incident or not," the Owasso Police Department's statement from Feb. 8 said. "A thorough investigation is being conducted by Owasso Police Detectives, and at this time no further information is being released, as this is an active investigation. The Owasso Police Department offers our condolences to the family, friends, fellow students and loved ones of the deceased student."Amid the news spreading on social media in the weeks following Benedict's death, the Owasso Police Department issued an update on the investigation on Feb. 20, saying "a thorough investigation is being conducted," and they are waiting on an autopsy report and toxicology results."There are laws regarding open records and confidential records and the Owasso Police Department will release all information required by law, but it is the Department’s policy to not release incident reports for cases that are under active investigation when there is risk of compromising or harming the investigation," Owasso Police Department officials said in the Feb. 20 update. "We understand that people are concerned about this incident and we can assure everyone that this incident is being taken seriously and is being investigated thoroughly."Court documents that KOCO 5 obtained gave further insight into police officers' response, including the following day when Benedict died.Around 2:50 p.m. on Feb. 8, Sue Benedict called 911 asking for medics for her 16-year-old. The affidavit states that the teenager was posturing and that their hands were curling, their eyes were rolling back and had shallow breathing.Sue Benedict "described her daughter getting into a fight at school yesterday where she hit her head on the bathroom floor," according to the affidavit. She also told the officer that the school advised her that "she may need to take her to the hospital because she was complaining of a headache."Owasso medics initiated CPR on the teenager and took them to St. Francis hospital around 3:20 p.m. on Feb. 8, "where she was later pronounced dead.""Owasso Police Officers suspect foul play involved and need to initiate an in-depth investigation into the death of the decedent and believe any relevant information held by Owasso Public Schools is necessary to do so," the affidavit says.A search warrant also shows that on Feb. 12, five days after the fight, police took 137 photos of the school and girls' bathroom where it happened, two swabs from stains found in the bathroom and records and documents of the students involved in the fight. Will charges be filed?On March 21, the Tulsa County District Attorney's Office said it will not file charges in connection to the teenager's death. The Tulsa County District Attorney's Office reviewed the Owasso Police Department's investigation into Benedict's death, saying they do not believe the filing of juvenile charges is warranted.| MORE | Therapists say Nex Benedict's death has domino effect on Oklahoma's LGBTQ+ community"From all the evidence gathered, this fight was an instance of mutual combat," Tulsa County District Attorney Stephen Kunzweiler wrote in a news release. "I do not have a reasonable belief that the State of Oklahoma could sustain its burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt if charges were presented for prosecution." The federal investigationThe U.S. Department of Education has launched a federal investigation into Owasso Public Schools following Benedict's death.| MORE | Federal Investigation launched into Owasso Public Schools following death of Nex BenedictU.S. Department of Education officials said they decided to open an investigation after receiving a complaint from the Human Rights Campaign.The complaint says, "we believe that Nex's death is the natural consequence of a growing wave of hatred against LGBTQ+ people." The complaint added that Oklahoma has considered more than 85 pieces of anti-LGBTQ+ legislation since 2015, passing seven into law.The department says it will determine whether Owasso Public Schools failed to appropriately respond to harassment of students. Investigators added that their goal is a quick resolution to the complaint.What is Owasso High School's bullying policy?According to Owasso High School's student handbook, bullying is defined as "any pattern of harassment, intimidation, threatening behavior, physical acts, verbal and electronic communication directed toward a student or group of students that results in or is reasonably perceived as being done with the intent to cause negative educational or physical results for the targeted individual or group and is communicated in such a way as to disrupt or interfere with the school's educational mission or the education of any student."The handbook continues saying "Owasso Public Schools strives to ensure a safe environment for every student." It says anyone who witnesses or receives a report of bullying is asked to provide information to an administrator, teacher or counselor so the district can take the appropriate action.

Nex Benedict, a 16-year-old nonbinary student, died on Feb. 8 – a day after authorities said they got into a fight in a bathroom at Owasso High School.

| MORE | Medical examiner's report on Nex Benedict's death prompts reaction from LGBTQ+ community

Advertisement

A little more than a month following the fight and Benedict's death, the Oklahoma Medical Examiner's Office released a summary autopsy report ruling the 16-year-old's death a suicide. Weeks later, the medical examiner released the full autopsy report into their death.

The student's death prompted a local and federal investigation and has made international headlines.

Below is a look at the circumstances surrounding Benedict's death and the investigation into it.

NOTE: The details below are disturbing. Also, KOCO 5 uses they/them pronouns for Nex Benedict, but this article uses direct quotes from those involved and court documents, which use she/her/daughter.

The autopsy report

On March 13, the Oklahoma State Medical Examiner's Office released a summary autopsy report stating Benedict's manner of death was a suicide.

The summary autopsy report from the medical examiner's office lists the probable cause of death as diphenhydramine and fluoxetine combined toxicity. Diphenhydramine is an antihistamine to relieve allergies, and fluoxetine is an antidepressant.

The full autopsy released on March 27 listed the toxicology report from Benedict.

Below are the results of the toxicology report:

  1. Fluoxetine:
    • 1.2 mcg/mL - (Hospital Blood A; 02/08/24 at 1600 hrs)
    • 1.9 mcg/mL - (Femoral Blood)

    2. Norfluoxetine:

    • 0.89 mcg/mL - (Hospital Blood A; 02/08/24 at 1600 hrs)
    • 1.4 mcg/mL - (Femoral Blood)

    3. Diphenhydramine

    • 15 mcg/mL - (Hospital Blood A; 02/08/24 at 1600 hrs)
    • 25 mcg/mL - (Femoral Blood)

    The autopsy found no lethal trauma to Benedict, but some bruises and cuts were found on their body. Investigators said that Benedict was reported to have headaches and seizure-like activity before they were found unresponsive.

    In late February, the Owasso Police Department released an investigation update saying preliminary information from the autopsy report indicated that Benedict did not die as a result of trauma.

    Handwritten notes that were also suggestive of self-harm were found in Benedict's bedroom and provided to law enforcement by their family, according to the report. There are resources available if you or anyone you know is struggling with mental health. You can call the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline by dialing 988.

    The bathroom fight

    According to police and Owasso Public Schools officials, a fight occurred on the afternoon of Feb. 7 in a bathroom on the west campus. They said the fight lasted for less than two minutes and was broken up by other students in the bathroom as well as a staff member supervising outside of the bathroom.

    Once the fight had been broken up, district officials said all students involved walked under their own power to the assistant principal's office and the nurse's office.

    | MORE | Parents of Owasso High School student who died correct errors of misidentifying their child

    Body camera video from an Owasso Police officer showed Benedict telling their account of what happened, saying they had finished stacking chairs in the lunch room and went to the bathroom. A group of freshmen also were in the bathroom when Benedict told the officer "I was talking with my friends, they were talking with their friends. And we were laughing, and they had said something like, 'Why do they laugh like that?' And they were talking about us in front of us."

    Benedict then said they poured water from a water bottle on the girls, "and all three of them came at me."

    "They came at me, they grabbed on my hair. I grabbed on them. I threw one of them into a paper towel dispenser, and then they got my legs out from under me," Benedict said. "Got me on the ground and started beating the (expletive) out of me. And then my friends tried to jump in and help, but I'm not sure. I blacked out."

    Security footage from Owasso High School showed that everyone involved in the fight was able to walk to the assistant principal's and nurse's offices under their own power.

    Why didn't the school call police?

    Although the district said Owasso High School administrators followed the initial protocols when a fight occurs, police said they were not notified of a fight happening on school grounds until an officer spoke with Benedict and their mother at the hospital.

    When speaking with Nex and Sue Benedict at the hospital, the body camera video shows that Sue Benedict wanted the officer to find out why school administrators didn't notify police of the fight.

    | MORE | Vigils held nationwide for nonbinary Oklahoma teenager who died day after school bathroom fight

    "They are in the wrong for that," Sue Benedict said.

    The officer told the Benedicts that he would get with the school the following morning to try to get information about the fight. He added "we'll definitely have a talk about that" about why police weren't notified of the fight.

    "They know better," the officer said. "And I will say for what it's worth, (name redacted), I've worked with her for five years. She's typically spot on, meaning the one who was with us in our conversation. She's one of the best in that school of handling. If I was a betting person, I would venture to say that there was something else a little more pressing that was going on – not that this was not. But I think, like anything, maybe it was a little overwhelming, maybe she had something else going on and it just slipped her mind probably. Because as soon as I sent her a text message that said, 'Do you know anything about a fight at school? Because I'm going to the ER,' and she was, 'Oh my gosh. Yes. Can I call you?'"

    The officer said the administrator said in the text exchange that there was an incident at the school and that they'd discuss it the following day.

    None of the statements from Owasso police or the school district addressed why police weren't called after the fight took place.

    The Owasso Police Department's investigation

    According to police, officers were called around 3:30 p.m. on Feb. 7 to Bailey Medical Center by the parent of a 16-year-old female Owasso High School student. The parent told police that they wanted to report that the student was involved in a physical altercation earlier that day while at Owasso High School.

    The police department's initial statement said, "No report of the fight was made to Owasso police prior to the notification at the hospital." Information was taken by a school resource officer who responded to the hospital.

    | MORE | Owasso police officers suspected foul play was involved in Nex Benedict’s death, affidavit says

    On Feb. 8, the Owasso Police Department learned that the 16-year-old was rushed back to the hospital, where the student was pronounced dead.

    "It is not known at this time if this latest medical incident is related to the previous incident or not," the Owasso Police Department's statement from Feb. 8 said. "A thorough investigation is being conducted by Owasso Police Detectives, and at this time no further information is being released, as this is an active investigation. The Owasso Police Department offers our condolences to the family, friends, fellow students and loved ones of the deceased student."

    Amid the news spreading on social media in the weeks following Benedict's death, the Owasso Police Department issued an update on the investigation on Feb. 20, saying "a thorough investigation is being conducted," and they are waiting on an autopsy report and toxicology results.

    "There are laws regarding open records and confidential records and the Owasso Police Department will release all information required by law, but it is the Department’s policy to not release incident reports for cases that are under active investigation when there is risk of compromising or harming the investigation," Owasso Police Department officials said in the Feb. 20 update. "We understand that people are concerned about this incident and we can assure everyone that this incident is being taken seriously and is being investigated thoroughly."

    Court documents that KOCO 5 obtained gave further insight into police officers' response, including the following day when Benedict died.

    Around 2:50 p.m. on Feb. 8, Sue Benedict called 911 asking for medics for her 16-year-old. The affidavit states that the teenager was posturing and that their hands were curling, their eyes were rolling back and had shallow breathing.

    Sue Benedict "described her daughter getting into a fight at school yesterday where she hit her head on the bathroom floor," according to the affidavit. She also told the officer that the school advised her that "she may need to take her to the hospital because she was complaining of a headache."

    Owasso medics initiated CPR on the teenager and took them to St. Francis hospital around 3:20 p.m. on Feb. 8, "where she was later pronounced dead."

    "Owasso Police Officers suspect foul play involved and need to initiate an in-depth investigation into the death of the decedent and believe any relevant information held by Owasso Public Schools is necessary to do so," the affidavit says.

    A search warrant also shows that on Feb. 12, five days after the fight, police took 137 photos of the school and girls' bathroom where it happened, two swabs from stains found in the bathroom and records and documents of the students involved in the fight.

    Will charges be filed?

    On March 21, the Tulsa County District Attorney's Office said it will not file charges in connection to the teenager's death.

    The Tulsa County District Attorney's Office reviewed the Owasso Police Department's investigation into Benedict's death, saying they do not believe the filing of juvenile charges is warranted.

    | MORE | Therapists say Nex Benedict's death has domino effect on Oklahoma's LGBTQ+ community

    "From all the evidence gathered, this fight was an instance of mutual combat," Tulsa County District Attorney Stephen Kunzweiler wrote in a news release. "I do not have a reasonable belief that the State of Oklahoma could sustain its burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt if charges were presented for prosecution."

    The federal investigation

    The U.S. Department of Education has launched a federal investigation into Owasso Public Schools following Benedict's death.

    | MORE | Federal Investigation launched into Owasso Public Schools following death of Nex Benedict

    U.S. Department of Education officials said they decided to open an investigation after receiving a complaint from the Human Rights Campaign.

    The complaint says, "we believe that Nex's death is the natural consequence of a growing wave of hatred against LGBTQ+ people." The complaint added that Oklahoma has considered more than 85 pieces of anti-LGBTQ+ legislation since 2015, passing seven into law.

    The department says it will determine whether Owasso Public Schools failed to appropriately respond to harassment of students. Investigators added that their goal is a quick resolution to the complaint.

    What is Owasso High School's bullying policy?

    According to Owasso High School's student handbook, bullying is defined as "any pattern of harassment, intimidation, threatening behavior, physical acts, verbal and electronic communication directed toward a student or group of students that results in or is reasonably perceived as being done with the intent to cause negative educational or physical results for the targeted individual or group and is communicated in such a way as to disrupt or interfere with the school's educational mission or the education of any student."

    The handbook continues saying "Owasso Public Schools strives to ensure a safe environment for every student." It says anyone who witnesses or receives a report of bullying is asked to provide information to an administrator, teacher or counselor so the district can take the appropriate action.