Skip to content
NOWCAST KOCO 10pm-10:30pm Sunday Night
Live Now
Advertisement

Baby Formula Wars: Are more expensive products really better?

Experts told parents not the over think it

Baby Formula Wars: Are more expensive products really better?

Experts told parents not the over think it

PICKING WHAT’S BEST FOR YOUR CHILD. I’M USUALLY LIKE, FILL UP BOTTLES SO THAT THEY’RE JUST READY TO GO. ALISSA TURAY IS A MOTHER OF TWO UNDER TWO. MY DAUGHTER IS 18 MONTHS OLD AND MY SON IS SIX MONTHS OLD. ALISSA TRIED BREASTFEEDING HER DAUGHTER, BUT IT WASN’T WORKING FOR HER. ABOUT A MONTH IN, SHE TRANSITIONED TO FORMULA FEEDING, SOMETHING SHE WAS NERVOUS ABOUT AT FIRST. ULTIMATELY, LIKE WHEN I SWITCHED TO FORMULA, I KNEW SHE WAS EATING AS MUCH AS SHE NEEDED TO. I KNEW SHE WAS GETTING FULL. SHE STARTED GAINING WEIGHT A LOT BETTER. SHE WAS CLEARLY LIKE A HEALTHY BABY. FORMULA FEEDING CAN GET EXPENSIVE. THANKFULLY FOR MANY OKLAHOMA FAMILIES, WHIC IS A MONEY SAVER. SO I HAVE LIKE A LITTLE STATION SET UP. IT’S NOT LIKE STOCKED RIGHT NOW THROUGH WHIC AMBER SAYS THEY GET ABOUT TEN OF THE SMALLER SIZE GERBER CANS A MONTH. IF WE DIDN’T HAVE WHIC, I THINK WE WOULD PROBABLY BE. SPENDING 3 TO 400 ON FORMULA A MONTH. BUT EVEN WITH WHIC, THEY’VE HAD TO BUY EXTRAS AS THEIR BABY GETS OLDER AND EATS MORE. WHEN THAT HAPPENS, THEY SOMETIMES OPT FOR THE STORE BRAND FOR THE MOST PART. WHENEVER WE WOULD USE THE STORE BRAND LIKE THAT WOULD JUST WORK FINE. AND THAT WAS ALWAYS LIKE THE CHEAPER OPTION. WHEN YOU’RE BUYING LIKE A $50 CAN. BEING A FIRST TIME MOM MYSELF, WHEN I MADE THE SWITCH TO FORMULA FEEDING, THE COST WAS EYE OPENING. AND AS SHE GOT OLDER, THIS NEARLY $50 CAN WOULDN’T EVEN LAST US A WEEK. SO I WONDERED, ARE THE MORE AFFORDABLE OPTIONS THE SAME? WHAT DO PARENTS NEED TO KNOW WHEN IT COMES TO CHOOSING THE RIGHT FORMULA FOR THEIR CHILD? YEAH, YOU KNOW THE NUMBER OF BRANDS MAKE IT SO HARD, BUT THE REALITY IS THAT THE SCIENCE OF FORMULA HAS COME SO FAR. DOCTOR CATHERINE MIMS IS A PEDIATRICIAN AT OU CHILDREN’S HEALTH. SHE SAYS FORMULAS TODAY ARE ABOUT AS CLOSE TO BREAST MILK AS POSSIBLE, AND THEY’RE ALL ESSENTIALLY THE SAME. GERBER, SIMILAC AND FEMALE IN STORE BRANDS. THE SAME. SOME BRANDS ARE ACTUALLY OTHER BRANDS, JUST REPACKAGED THE PRICE OF FORMULA, THOUGH, IS ANYTHING BUT THE SAME. A 30.8OZ CAN OF SIMILAC 360 TOTAL CARE WILL COST YOU ABOUT $50. A 28 OUNCE CAN OF ENFAMIL NEUROPRO IS NEARLY $47. MEANWHILE, WHILE A 33.2OZ CAN OF PARENTS CHOICE ADVANTAGE IS JUST UNDER $30, AND TARGET’S UP AND UP ADVANTAGE PREMIUM 36 OUNCE CAN IS $35. I USED TO BUY THE SIMILAC EXPENSIVE ONE FROM COSTCO AND I REALIZED ACTUALLY, THEY’RE THE SAME FORMULA REPACKAGED AND SO KIRKLAND’S, IT WAS DOCTOR MIMS SAYS NEW PARENTS OFTEN ASK IF IT’S OKAY TO SWITCH FORMULAS, ESPECIALLY AFTER THEY’VE USED THE NAME BRAND USED AT THE HOSPITAL. WELL, IT’S A REAL STRUGGLE, LIKE TRYING TO REASSURE PARENTS THAT, LIKE GOING TO A CHEAPER BRAND IS NOT USING A LESSER FORMULA. WHETHER YOU HAVE TO SWITCH BECAUSE YOU’RE ON WICK OR YOU PREFER A CERTAIN BRAND OVER ANOTHER, IT’S ALL OKAY, DOCTOR MIMS SAYS. WHATEVER WORKS FOR YOU AND YOUR BABY IS THE RIGHT CHOICE. I TELL PARENTS LIKE, DON’T, DON’T OVERTHINK IT. WHAT YOU CAN AFFORD IS WHAT YOU SHOULD BUY. IF YOUR BABY HAS ANY
Advertisement
Baby Formula Wars: Are more expensive products really better?

Experts told parents not the over think it

Formula feeding can be expensive for families. KOCO 5 looked into the best options to help Oklahomans save money and stay healthy. Alyssa Turay has two children under 2 years old. "My daughter is 18 months, and my son is 6 months old," Turay said. She tried breastfeeding her daughter, but it wasn't working for her. About one month in, she transitioned to formula feeding, something she was nervous about at first. Get the latest news stories of interest by clicking here."When I switched to formula, I knew she was eating as much as she needed to. I knew she was getting full. She was gaining weight a lot better, and she was clearly a healthy baby," Turay said. Formula feeding can get expensive. For many families, WIC is a money saver. Through the program, Turay said they get about 10 of the smaller-sized Gerber cans a month. "If we didn't have WIC, I think we'd probably be spending $300 to $400 a month," Turay said. Even with the assistance, she said they have had to buy extra as their baby gets older and eats more. When that happens, they sometimes opt for the store brand. "For the most part, whenever we would use the store brand, that would work just fine. That was always the cheaper option when you're buying a $50 can," Turay said. KOCO 5's Alejandra Briones recently became a first-time mom. She said the cost of formula feeding was eye-opening. As her child got older, Briones said a nearly $50 can didn't last her a week. Wondering if the more affordable formulas were the same, she turned to the experts. "The number of brands makes it so hard. But the reality is that the science of formula has come so far," said Catherine Mims, a pediatrician at Oklahoma Children's Hospital OU Health. She said formulas are about as close to breast milk as possible. "And they're all essentially the same," Mims said. "Some brands are actually other brands repackaged."The price of formula is anything but the same. A 30.8-ounce can of Similac 360 Total Care will cost families about $50. A 28-ounce can of Enfamil Neuro Pro is nearly $47. Meanwhile, a 33.2-ounce can of Parent's Choice Advantage is just under $30. Target's Up and Up Advantage Premium is $35 for a 36-ounce can. "I used to buy the Similac expensive one from Costco, and I realized, actually, they're the same formula repackaged! And so Kirkland's it was," Mims said. Mims said new parents often ask if it's OK to switch formulas, especially after they have used the name brand at the hospital. >> Download the KOCO 5 app"It's a real struggle trying to reassure parents that going to a cheaper brand is not using a lesser formula," Mims said. Whether families have to switch because they are on WIC or prefer a certain brand over another, it's all OK. Mims said whatever works for families is the right choice. "I tell parents, don't overthink it. What you can afford is what you should buy," Mims said. If a baby has any sensitivities, experts recommend talking to a pediatrician. Top Headlines Tornado watch continues as storms move across Oklahoma ME lists manner of death for 16-year-old nonbinary student Nex Benedict as suicide Woman found dead in a Florida canal has been identified after nearly 42 years Police officer opens fire and kills dog during traffic stop in northeast Oklahoma City Oklahoma family issues warning on rare, deadly disease found in lakes

Formula feeding can be expensive for families. KOCO 5 looked into the best options to help Oklahomans save money and stay healthy.

Alyssa Turay has two children under 2 years old.

Advertisement

"My daughter is 18 months, and my son is 6 months old," Turay said.

She tried breastfeeding her daughter, but it wasn't working for her. About one month in, she transitioned to formula feeding, something she was nervous about at first.

Get the latest news stories of interest by clicking here.

"When I switched to formula, I knew she was eating as much as she needed to. I knew she was getting full. She was gaining weight a lot better, and she was clearly a healthy baby," Turay said.

Formula feeding can get expensive. For many families, WIC is a money saver. Through the program, Turay said they get about 10 of the smaller-sized Gerber cans a month.

"If we didn't have WIC, I think we'd probably be spending $300 to $400 a month," Turay said.

Even with the assistance, she said they have had to buy extra as their baby gets older and eats more. When that happens, they sometimes opt for the store brand.

"For the most part, whenever we would use the store brand, that would work just fine. That was always the cheaper option when you're buying a $50 can," Turay said.

KOCO 5's Alejandra Briones recently became a first-time mom. She said the cost of formula feeding was eye-opening.

As her child got older, Briones said a nearly $50 can didn't last her a week. Wondering if the more affordable formulas were the same, she turned to the experts.

"The number of brands makes it so hard. But the reality is that the science of formula has come so far," said Catherine Mims, a pediatrician at Oklahoma Children's Hospital OU Health.

She said formulas are about as close to breast milk as possible.

"And they're all essentially the same," Mims said. "Some brands are actually other brands repackaged."

The price of formula is anything but the same. A 30.8-ounce can of Similac 360 Total Care will cost families about $50. A 28-ounce can of Enfamil Neuro Pro is nearly $47.

Meanwhile, a 33.2-ounce can of Parent's Choice Advantage is just under $30. Target's Up and Up Advantage Premium is $35 for a 36-ounce can.

"I used to buy the Similac expensive one from Costco, and I realized, actually, they're the same formula repackaged! And so Kirkland's it was," Mims said.

Mims said new parents often ask if it's OK to switch formulas, especially after they have used the name brand at the hospital.

>> Download the KOCO 5 app

"It's a real struggle trying to reassure parents that going to a cheaper brand is not using a lesser formula," Mims said.

Whether families have to switch because they are on WIC or prefer a certain brand over another, it's all OK. Mims said whatever works for families is the right choice.

"I tell parents, don't overthink it. What you can afford is what you should buy," Mims said.

If a baby has any sensitivities, experts recommend talking to a pediatrician.


Top Headlines